Skip to main content

CRUSHED: Melania’s debut humiliation

#30 of 84 articles from the Special Report: U.S. Presidential Election 2016
Melania Trump’s RNC speech broadcast live on Cleveland streets Photo credit: Mac Boucher for National Observer

Support strong Canadian climate journalism for 2025

Help us raise $150,000 by December 31. Can we count on your support?
Goal: $150k
$32k

Is there a more fitting symbol of the entire Trump campaign than the image of poor captive Melania mouthing a plagiarized speech on integrity? The original, it's been pointed out, was written by Sarah Hurwitz, Hillary Clinton's own speechwriter.

Fraudulence. Incompetence. Quackery. Hackery.

Yet the killer piece is the endless looping reel juxtaposing a helplessly stilted Stepford wife struggling to parrot the real thing and genuine article: the confident brilliance of Michelle Obama.

Comparing Melania Trump's 2016 RNC speech with Michelle Obama in 2008

There is a crushing tragedy for Melania Trump in all of this. I'm afraid I can't join the "serves her right" crowd, although there's no question whatsoever that if Michelle Obama had done anything like it she would never be forgiven.

But Michelle Obama is not a weakly-educated trophy model thrust far beyond her depth by her desperate narcissist of a husband. That Melania Trump is both profoundly uncomfortable and manifestly unsuited to the role her husband has picked out for her is just one more example of his abject disregard of women.

As if we needed any more.

Of course no speech writer was fired over this absurd escapade, because, well, who do you think wrote the damned thing? Who else would be allowed to put words in the mouth of Donald Trump's wife except the man himself?

And for a man like Donald Trump, nothing could reflect his own power more than his wife. The stage-craft of Melania's debut on the world scene at the Republican National Convention was pure Donald. His over-the top back-lit entrance to introduce her (no one else could be trusted with that job), the radiantly pure white dress, the face botoxed and and filled into a frozen mask.

All of it a religious idolatry reflecting glory onto Trump.

Cleveland crowd watches Melania Trump's speech to the Republican National Convention Photo by Mac Boucher

Melania, of course, is just a prop. A model prisoner.

Who is she?

Don't ask. You're not supposed to know. Just gaze in wonder. It'll all be over soon.

Comments