Support strong Canadian climate journalism for 2025
This article was originally published by Grist on Aug. 27, 2018. It was republished as part of climatedesk, a journalistic collaboration dedicated to exploring the impact — human, environmental, economic and political— of a changing climate.
Dozens of epitaphs written over the weekend proclaim the late U.S. Senator John McCain as an American hero. But history may miss one of his greatest achievements: His decades-long call for climate action.
The death of McCain, Arizona’s senior senator, former prisoner of war, avid outdoorsman, and two-time Republican presidential candidate, marks the end of an era of free-thinking moderate conservatives who embraced conservation as a core value.
On the campaign trail in 2000, McCain received question after question from young people on climate change. After looking into it, he realized something major had to be done. In a 2007 interview with Grist, McCain explains his reasoning succinctly: “Suppose we’re wrong, and there’s no such thing as greenhouse gas emissions, and we adopt green technologies. All we’ve done is give our kids a better planet.”
Before Barack Obama’s environmental policies, before the Paris Agreement, there was McCain-Lieberman — the 2001 cap-and-trade proposal that McCain championed during a time when the country would soon be consumed with fighting a global war on terrorism. McCain-Lieberman never passed the Senate, but it remains the most important bipartisan U.S. climate legislation ever proposed, inspiring cap-and-trade schemes that have been implemented around the world.
On the 2008 campaign trail, this time as the GOP’s presidential nominee, he delivered what might be one of the most accurate, urgent, and passionate speeches ever given by a major American political figure on climate change. The entire address is worth reading in full, if only to lament how far his rhetoric seems from the realm of possibility today after a decade of Republican backsliding on this most-important of issues.
For example, the most stalwart of climate champions could have written this particular passage:
We have many advantages in the fight against global warming, but time is not one of them. Instead of idly debating the precise extent of global warming, or the precise timeline of global warming, we need to deal with the central facts of rising temperatures, rising waters, and all the endless troubles that global warming will bring. We stand warned by serious and credible scientists across the world that time is short and the dangers are great. The most relevant question now is whether our own government is equal to the challenge.
Of course, McCain also had his own share of backsliding on climate. His insistence on market-based climate solutions made him a frequent opponent of Obama’s regulatory approach. His nomination of Sarah Palin — the Alaska governor who popularized the “drill, baby, drill” chant — as his running mate in 2008 played a major role in unleashing a wave anti-science populism that led to our country’s present leadership. In his final days, McCain said picking Palin was one of his biggest regrets.
But McCain wasn’t afraid to bravely stand up to his own party and advocate for the environment, especially during the Trump era. McCain was one of the few Republicans strongly speaking out against the planned withdrawal from the Paris climate agreement — traveling to Australia’s Great Barrier Reef to make his plea that the U.S. keep its commitment. And last year, McCain was still cheering on climate activists and chose to buck his party’s anti-science stances and uphold an Obama-era methane rule.
In this moment of deep division and existential challenges facing our country and our world, we’d do well to emulate McCain’s spirit of courage and ability to stand up for urgent climate action even when other problems seem all-encompassing. In his final months, when asked what he’d like to be remembered for, he wanted people to say that “he served his country.”
John McCain served his planet, too.
Comments
Is this a joke? I had to read it several times. John McCain is a war criminal who has killed and help kill thousands of people. How can you do that and then say he is ok because he wrapped himself in the green movement.
This is a jaw dropping ignorant article or its pure propangda. The narritive is everything -- challenge it.
Incredible bs
The bar you set for environmental excellence is so low that earthworms can barely limbo under it. Eulogizing war fanatic and US imperial potentate John McCain as a Republican with a climate conscience really made me choke on my tofu candy. Is the writer in a historical coma?.
John McCain was everything Trump is not. RIP Senator McCain.
Neil and Carol: You appear to have little room for complexity and ambiguity in human beings and reality.
Yes... the world is a complex and ambiguous place and reality is also not just black and white ...except that everyone dies and your taxes are due in March. McCain’s death, while tragic to those who loved him, is not a world of hurt for those who are opposed to those who preach war as a balm for the ills of humanity. The dearth of climate change warriors in the Republican Party has been a grease stain on the soul of the world because of the immense power of the US state. McCain’s feeble voice is a whisper in the wind when compared to what is needed.
However, If he had turned up at Standing Rock, as his ‘come to Jesus’ climate awareness moment, l would definitely have deepened my awareness of the ambiguity of his redemption. For the millions of Vietnamese that he lovingly dismissed as “gooks”, for the Iranians, Lybians, and Iraqis that he applauded the bombing of, reality is a bitch and not as ambiguous as you may think.