Support strong Canadian climate journalism for 2025
Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer faced strong criticism from nutrition experts on Thursday after he pledged to review the new Canada Food Guide should the Tories win power this fall.
Scheer, who spoke at an annual meeting of the Dairy Farmers of Canada in Saskatoon on Wednesday, said the process to craft the new version of the document released in January was "flawed" and that the guide needs to reflect what "science tells us."
The overhauled document did away with traditional food groups and portion sizes and focused instead on broader guidelines, including eating more plant-based protein and drinking more water.
At the Wednesday event, Scheer faced a question from a woman who identified herself as a dairy producer from British Columbia who asked for his stance was on the existing healthy-eating strategy and what dairy farmers can expect in terms of food policy in Canada.
"Absolutely, we are going to review that Canada Food Guide," Scheer said in response, adding there was a "complete lack of consultation" on the new version.
Video of his remarks was posted by CTV News and was verified by the Conservatives.
Health Canada says it began consultations in fall 2016 in a process open to Canadians and all stakeholders, including industry. The results were then published in a report.
In summer 2017, Health Canada completed a second consultation where draft eating recommendations were presented.
The department also said its officials responsible for drafting the recommendations did not meet with food and beverage industry representatives to discuss the document — a deliberate decision made in hopes of ensuring its dietary guidance was based on "scientific evidence and free from conflict of interest."
Dr. Yoni Freedhoff, a professor at the University of Ottawa who specializes in obesity, said that the only explanation for Scheer's comments, which he described as "intensely stupid," is that they are meant to curry political favour.
During his bid to become Conservative leader, Scheer garnered support from members of the dairy industry that helped him to edge out his main competitor, Maxime Bernier. Scheer won the leadership over Bernier by a whisker.
Freedhoff, who has been strongly outspoken about problems he's seen with previous versions of the Food Guide, said the newest version is by far the best one Canada has ever produced. He said it might be the best such guide in the world.
"It is biased in favour of health, evidence and science," he said in an interview. "And that is the way it should be."
Previous versions of the influential document were biased in favour of industry, Freedhoff said, adding former governments allowed industry to affect the process in a way that undermined public health.
While some Canadians might think of the Food Guide as offering guidance for grocery shopping, he pointed out that it's used by institutions such as schools, hospitals and long-term care facilities, where people have little control over what they get to eat.
On Thursday, Dietitians of Canada tweeted that the new guide is most definitely based on science, adding it encourages people to eat vegetables, fruits, whole grains and protein foods, including dairy.
The Canadian Digestive Health Foundation said Scheer's comments were not backed up or founded by any scientific data, adding it supports the current direction of Canada's Food Guide.
Health Minister Ginette Petitpas Taylor also issued a statement in response to Scheer that accuses him of "spreading lies" about the guide.
"Health policy should be based on evidence not industry, and meet the needs of all Canadians," she said.
Come October, Canadians will have a "clear choice" between a party focused on pleasing big business and lobby groups and a party focused on keeping Canadians healthy, she added.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said the guide is based on evidence, science and research in order to serve Canadian families and has nothing to do with politics.
"But I'm not surprised the Conservatives don't get that. We all remember they declared war on the long-form census. Now they seem to be declaring war on the Canada Food Guide," he told reporters in Victoria.
"We're going to continue to focus on evidence and science as a way of making policy and supporting Canadian families in their choices."
Comments
Quite apart from the food guide's ignorance of food deserts, and its failure to acknowledge the growing incidence of food related body disfunction, and the loading of contaminants in those at the top of the food chain: political commentary on the food guide is even more ignorant and misguided than the deliberations of the nutritional experts.
When expert panels make recomendations based on some mythical average human they ignore whole swaths of people who cannot, for whatever reason, follow their magisterial pronouncements. Most of humanity survives as best it can in the face of psychopathic corporate manipulation that has no other goal than profitable self survival.
It has not actually been that many generations between the people who mostly ate what they themselves, or their neighbors grew. Following WWII consolidation of local/regional food processors into multinationals removed the consumer from the equation and profit - at any cost - became the modus operandi.
In less than four generations we see evolution at work. Humans in "advanced" societies are morphing into bloated, unhealthy, organisms. Plagued by a variety of self inflicted ills. Genetics are changing to produce oversized infants, prematurely maturing children, and a growing segment of surviving, unfit, medically dependent populations who are living long enough to pass on their faulty genetic material. It looks like an aberrant evolutionary dead end.
I would suggest that Mr. Scheer read "The China Study" by T. Colin Campbell, PhD, and Thomas M. Campbell II, MD, which summarizes the findings in the largest study ever done relating disease incidence to nutrition. Needless to say, its findings overwhelming point out that a plant based diet is the most disease preventative.